Sunday 27 April 2014

European integration: KEY DATES


1945: UN founded
1946: Churchill "Iron curtain" speech (5 March) marks start of Cold War
1946: Churchill "United States of Europe" speech (19 September)
1948: Benelux created
1948OEEC set up to manage Marshall Plan aid (April)
1948: Hague Congress (7-11 May)
1949: Washington Treaty sets up NATO (4 April)
1949: Treaty of London sets up the Council of Europe (5 May)
1950: Schuman Declaration (9th May)
1951: Treaty of Paris creates the ECSC, first supranational European institution
1952: European Defence Community rejected in 1954
1955: Messina Conference
1957: Treaties of Rome signed by 6 countries (EEC and Euratom)
1958: European Court of Justice set up
1958: Charles de Gaulle elected President Vth Republic
1963: Charles de Gaulle vetoes UK entry (also in 1967)
1963Élysée Treaty
1965: Merger Treaty
1969: Georges Pompidou elected president, Willy Brand elected Chancellor
1969: Hague Summit
1972: Paris European Summit
1973: +3 (9)
1975: British referendum on continued EEC membership
1979: Universal suffrage to the European Parliament
1979: Margaret Thatcher elected Prime Minister
1981: +1 (10)
1985: Schengen Accords (comes into force in 1995)
1986: +2 (12)
1986: Single European Act
1992: Treaty Establishing the European Union ("Maastricht")
1995: +3 (15)
1995: Constitution rejected
1997: Treaty of Amsterdam
2001: Treaty of Nice (+ Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union)
2002: Eurozone
2004: +10 (25)
2007: +2 (27)
2007: Great Recession starts
2007: Treaty of Lisbon
2013: +1 (28)

European integration : KEY CONCEPTS

EU citizenship : Any person who holds the nationality of a European Union country is automatically also an EU citizen (cf. 1992 Maastricht Treaty).

Confederation: A union of states in which each member state retains some independent control over internal and external affairs. Thus, for international purposes, there are separate states, not just one state.

Federalism: A union of states (in which external affairs are controlled by a unified, central government).

Neo-functionalism : Theory which explains European integration as successful cooperation between countries in one sector (trade) encouraging attempts at cooperation in other sectors (politics, defence, etc.).

Governance: Government at a supranational level.

National sovereignty: The power of a state to do everything necessary to govern itself, such as making, executing, and applying laws; imposing and collecting taxes; making war and peace; and forming treaties or engaging in commerce with foreign nations.

Regionalism: Cooperation between the countries of a continent (regional integrating organizations such as ASEAN, NAFTA, the EU, and the African Union, promote regionalism). The EU is different from the other regional integrating organizations because it is not just about economic cooperation but also about increasing political cooperation (integration, unity).

Supranational government: "Supranational" is a legal term, first used in the Paris Treaty of 1951 which founded the ECSC, to describe a type of democratic organization (a "Community") in which governments delegate to a multi-national organization part of their power. The creation of a wider (enlarged) and deeper (more integrated) Europe rests on this system of Community.

The attempt to unify Europe politically since the 1948 Hague Congress: INTRODUCTION


After the havoc of World War Two, many people and politicians felt that cooperation between the countries of Europe was necessary to bring security, lasting peace, and stability for economic growth. People feared a return to ultra-nationalism, to racial and ethnic hatred. They also feared political extremism from within Europe and from the USSR.

The EEC (1957 to 1992) and the European Union (since 1992) have been the relatively successful means to organize the efforts at cooperation. From an economic point of view, and despite the Great Recession which started in 2008, the European post-war project  has been quite successful. Political integration however has been more difficult; Europeans continue to find it difficult to agree who should decide: the centralized supra-national institutions (“Brussels”) or first and foremost the Member States.


Even before the end of the War, the idea of a European federation was already being discussed. From 1945, politicians (mostly Christian Democrats like Monnet Schuman, De Gasperi, Adenauer) started thinking about how to make it a reality. The Marshall Plan aid also encouraged cooperation between western European countries (so that there would be a united front against the spread of Communism from the East). The OEEC (Organization for European Cooperation) distributed the aid.

The 1948 Hague Congress brought together people and groups interested in promoting a united Europe; as a result, the Council of Europe was set up to promote human rights and democracy.

Following the Schuman Declaration (9th May 1950), the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) was set up in 1951. The members were: France, Federal Republic of Germany, Italy, Belgium, Netherlands and Luxemburg. The idea was to manage together strategic resources rather than fighting for them. The ECSC (“CECA” in French) was the precursor of the EEC.

The 1954 plan for a common European defence force (Communauté de Défense Européenne) was not carried out because France was worried about Germany being allowed to have a bigger army.

The 1955 Messine conference led to the signature of the Rome Treaties on 25th March 1957 which set up the EEC and Euratom. The aim of the European Economic Community was economic cooperation, a "common market". The institutions set up to manage it took on progressively more power.

The number of member countries has increased from 6 to 28 in less than sixty years. New members have to be democratic and have a market economy.

In 1957, 6 countries made up the EEC: France + Germany + Italy + Netherlands + Belgium + Luxembourg

1973: +3 (UK, Ireland, Denmark) = 9

1981: + 1 (Greece) = 10

In 1985, the Schengen Accords were signed, getting rid of internal EU borders (UK and Ireland did not sign).

1986: + 2 (Spain, Portugal) = 12

In 1992, the EEC is replaced by the EU following the signature of the Maastricht Treaty.

1995: + 3 (Sweden, Finland, Austria) = 15

In 2001, the Nice Treaty adopts the principle of a qualified majority (3/4 of the Member states have to be in favor), replacing unanimous votes so as to make decision-making easier in a union that counts more and more members.

In 2002, the Euro replaces the national currencies of the Eurozone countries.

2004: + 10 (Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary, Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia, Malta, Slovenia, Cyprus) = 25

In 2005, the proposal for a European Constitution was abandoned after being rejected in French and Dutch referendums.

In 2007, the Lisbon Treaty created the job of European Council President.

2007: + 2 (Romania, Bulgaria) = 27

2013: + 1 (Croatia) = 28

Member states in the EU cohabit with the supranational European institutions; decisions made by the EU institutions are applied by the Member states (this is called the principle of "subsidiarity").

There are two other ways Europe could be run: 

  • one in which the States would always have the prerogative (i.e. final say) in European matters (this is called "souverainism" or "confederalism");
  • the other in which there would be a strong centralized European government (this is called "federalism", a kind of “united states of Europe”).
The EU is still in the making and does not have the support of all citizens or politicians (there is no unique vision of what the EU should be “for” or how it should be run). It is often criticized for being bureaucratic, complex, and too “distant” (far from people’s daily preoccupations), hence the rejection of the European Constitution in 2005 and the increasing abstention rate at European Parliament elections.

However, European citizenship and initiatives like ERASMUS have contributed to the sense of a European identity. For the while, Europe has a “variable geometry” (core countries are integrating faster than others): not all countries are members of the Eurozone or have signed the Schengen accords. However, the EU is still attractive to countries outside it, hence its enlargement.

Saturday 26 April 2014

What were the ideological differences between the USSR and the USA during the Cold War?

Document 1: US 1950s film poster



Document 2: Extract of a speech given by President Harry S. Truman delivered on 12th March 1947 before a Joint Session of Congress

“At the present moment in world history nearly every nation must choose between alternative ways of life. The choice is too often not a free one.

One way of life is based upon the will of the majority, and is distinguished by free institutions, representative government, free elections, guarantees of individual liberty, freedom of speech and religion, and freedom from political oppression.

The second way of life is based upon the will of a minority forcibly imposed upon the majority. It relies upon terror and oppression, a controlled press and radio, fixed elections, and the suppression of personal freedoms.

I believe that it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures.”

Sunday 13 April 2014

To what extent were the 1960s and 1970s a period of “détente” between the superpowers?

Document 1:

Text adapted from the NASA mission narrative for the Apollo-Soyuz flight, a joint initiative by the USA and USSR.

…Voice contact was made soon after. “Hello Soyuz!” Stafford said in Russian. Kubasov replied in English: “Hello everybody, hi to you Tom and Deke, hello there, Vance!”

All communications among the five crew members during the mission were made in the language of the listener, with the Americans speaking Russian to the Soviet crew and the Soviet crew speaking English to the Americans.

Contact of the two spacecraft, at 12:09 pm on July 17th 1975, was transmitted live on TV to the earth, and Stafford commented: “We have succeeded, everything is excellent.” “Soyuz and Apollo are shaking hands now” the cosmonauts answered.

Hard docking was completed over the Atlantic Ocean at 12:12 pm, 6 minutes earlier than the prelaunch flight plan, watched by millions of TV viewers worldwide. “Perfect, beautiful, well done, Tom, it was a good show, we're looking forward to shaking hands with you on board Soyuz” Leonov said. (…)

Both Soviet Communist Party General Secretary Leonid Brezhnev and US President Gerald Ford congratulated the crews and expressed their confidence in the success of the mission.

Stafford then presented Leonov with “flags for your government and the people of the Soviet Union” with the wish that “our joint work in space serves for the benefit of all countries and peoples on the earth”. Leonov then presented the U.S. crew with Soviet flags. (…)

The hatches were closed after Brand told Leonov and Kubasov: “I'm sure that we've opened up a new era in history.”



Document 2:

1968 drawing by Opland, a Dutch cartoonist